A material event is any development after your 409A valuation date that may materially change the value of your company. Common examples are a new funding round, a signed term sheet, an acquisition offer or the loss of a major customer. Once a material event happens, the existing 409A valuation should not be used to price new stock options, even if it is less than 12 months old.
KEY POINTS
- The IRS regulation does not list material events. It asks whether new information may materially affect the value of the company.
- A 409A valuation stops supporting new option grants at the earlier of 12 months or a material event.
- Financing events, including SAFEs and convertible notes, are the most common material events.
- Bad news counts too. A material event can lower the value of common stock as well as raise it.
- A material event affects new grants only. Options already granted at a supported price are not repriced.
What does the IRS rule say about material events?
The IRS rule does not use the phrase “material event”. Treasury Regulation 1.409A-1(b)(5)(iv)(B) says a valuation of private company stock is no longer reasonable at a later date if it fails to reflect information available after the valuation date that may materially affect the value of the company. The regulation gives two examples: the resolution of material litigation and the issuance of a patent.
The same regulation sets the 12 month limit that decides how long a 409A valuation stays valid. A 409A valuation supports an option grant only if two conditions hold on the grant date. The valuation date is no more than 12 months old, and nothing has happened since that date that may materially affect value.
“Material event” is the working label that valuers, lawyers and auditors use for the second condition. The regulation gives a test, not a list, so every event is judged on its own facts. The practical question is simple: would an informed buyer pay a different price for the common stock today because of what happened?
Which events usually count as material?
Events that give new evidence of what the company is worth, or that change its expected cash flows, usually count as material. Financing events are the most common. The table shows how valuation firms and startup counsel generally treat each event. It reflects common practice, not a list in the regulation.
| Event | Why it may change value | Usual step before the next grant |
|---|---|---|
| Priced equity round (seed, Series A or later) | Outside investors have negotiated a price for the company | New 409A valuation |
| SAFE or convertible note round | Investors price the company through a valuation cap or discount | New 409A valuation in most cases |
| Signed term sheet for a financing | The negotiated price is known before the round closes | Pause grants and ask the valuer |
| Acquisition offer or letter of intent | A buyer has put a price on the whole company | Pause grants, new 409A valuation |
| Secondary sale of common stock | A real transaction in the same class of stock as the options | Valuer reviews, often a new 409A valuation |
| Major customer contract won or lost | Forecast revenue changes | Valuer reviews |
| Results far above or below the forecast used in the last 409A | The last valuation relied on that forecast | Valuer reviews |
| Litigation resolved, patent issued or regulatory approval received | A major risk is removed or a major asset is added | Valuer reviews |
| Buying another business or selling a division | The company no longer owns the same assets | New 409A valuation |
A secondary sale of common stock needs its own analysis. The price a buyer pays in a secondary sale can include factors that do not apply to every share, so the valuer decides how much weight the sale price should carry.
Which events usually do not count as material?
Routine business activity usually does not count as a material event. Results that track the forecast used in the last 409A valuation are already built into that valuation. The same applies to hiring within plan, small customer wins, minor product updates and option grants from the existing pool.
Size matters, and it is measured against your company, not in absolute dollars. A $200,000 contract can be material for a pre-revenue startup and immaterial for a company with $20 million in annual revenue. When an event falls in between, ask the valuation provider and keep the answer on file.
Does a SAFE, convertible note or signed term sheet count?
Yes, in most cases. A SAFE (simple agreement for future equity) or convertible note sold to outside investors is new evidence of value, because the valuation cap or discount was negotiated at arm’s length. Most valuation firms and startup counsel treat it the same way as a priced round and expect a new 409A after a funding round.
The exception is narrow. A small bridge note from existing insiders on unchanged terms may tell the valuer little that is new. That call belongs to the valuer, and the detail of how SAFEs and convertible notes affect a 409A depends on the cap, the discount and the amount raised.
A signed term sheet counts before the round closes. The regulation looks at information available on the grant date, and a negotiated price in a signed term sheet is information the company already has. Granting options between signing and closing at the old price is one of the riskiest timing choices a board can make.
What happens if you grant options after a material event?
Options granted after a material event on the old valuation lose 409A safe harbor protection. Safe harbor means the IRS must accept the valuation unless it can show the valuation was grossly unreasonable. Without safe harbor, the company has to prove that the exercise price was at least fair market value on the grant date.
If the IRS decides the exercise price was below fair market value, the option is treated as deferred compensation that fails section 409A. The tax cost falls on the employee, not the company. The employee can owe income tax as the option vests, a 20% additional tax, and interest at the IRS underpayment rate plus 1 percentage point. The full list of 409A penalties also includes state taxes in some states.
The problem often surfaces before any IRS review. Financial statement auditors and buyers in an acquisition both compare grant dates against funding dates and valuation dates.
Not sure whether a recent event affects your 409A? Send us the facts before your next board meeting.
What should you do when a possible material event happens?
Stop granting options first, then get the event assessed. The steps below keep the grant record clean.
- Pause all pending option grants, including grants already promised in offer letters.
- Write down what happened and the date it happened. For a financing, use the term sheet date, not only the closing date.
- Send the facts to your valuation provider and ask in writing whether the event is material.
- If the event is material, get a new 409A valuation before the next grant. If it is not, keep the valuer’s written reply with your board records.
- Have the board approve new grants at the new price and refer to the new valuation report in the resolution.
- Count the next 12 months from the new valuation date.
What we see in practice?
The event we see missed most often is a SAFE round. Founders tell us it was “not a priced round”, so they kept granting options on the old 409A for months. The second is timing around a term sheet. The company signs, then approves a batch of grants before closing, expecting the old price to hold until the money arrives. Both leave grants that are hard to defend in diligence. We also see the reverse. A company loses a key customer or misses its forecast, keeps granting at the old price, and employees receive options priced above what the stock is worth.
When to get professional help?
You do not need a new valuation or outside help if your 409A is less than 12 months old, no financing or offer is in progress, and results are close to the forecast in the last report. Keep granting at the current price.
Get help when any event in the table above has happened, when a large grant is planned and you have any doubt, or when the board or an auditor asks for support for the price. Our 409A valuation service covers both the materiality question and the updated report.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a grace period to keep using the old 409A after a material event?
No. The regulation does not give a 30, 60 or 90 day window after a material event. Some companies use 90 days as an internal planning habit for ordering the new report, but any option granted after the event needs a valuation that reflects the event.
Can a material event lower a 409A value?
Yes. A material event is any information that may materially affect value, in either direction. Losing a major customer, a failed product trial or a down round can reduce the fair market value of common stock. A new 409A valuation then lets the company grant options at a lower exercise price.
Do options granted before the material event need to be repriced?
No. Fair market value is tested on the grant date of each option. Options granted earlier, at a price supported by a 409A valuation that was valid on their grant date, are not affected by an event that happens later.
Who decides whether an event is material?
The company decides, through its board, and the company carries the responsibility. The valuation provider gives a view on whether the event may materially affect value, and company counsel often weighs in. The IRS can review that decision later, which is why the reasoning should be in writing.
Does a new 409A after a material event restart the 12 months?
Yes. The 12 months run from the valuation date of the new report. The new 409A valuation then supports option grants until the earlier of 12 months from that date or the next material event.
Is reaching a revenue milestone a material event?
It depends on the forecast used in the last 409A valuation. Revenue that arrives in line with that forecast is already reflected in the value. Revenue far ahead of or behind the forecast may materially affect value, so send the numbers to the valuation provider before granting.
Had a funding round, term sheet or other change since your last 409A? Tell us what happened and we will confirm whether you need a new valuation before your next grant. See our 409A valuation services.
This page gives general information and is not advice for a specific situation.
