Skip to content Skip to footer

How Long Is a 409A Valuation Valid?

A 409A valuation is valid for up to 12 months from its valuation date, and only while no new information has come up that may materially affect the company’s value. The 12 months are measured to the date each option is granted. After 12 months, or after a material event such as a priced funding round, the company needs a new valuation before granting more options.

Key points

  • A 409A valuation can support stock option grants for a maximum of 12 months from the valuation date.
  • The 12 months run from the valuation date in the report, not the date the report was delivered, so the usable period is usually shorter than a year.
  • A material event, such as a priced funding round or an acquisition offer, can end the validity before 12 months.
  • An expired 409A valuation does not affect options already granted. It only stops the company from relying on it for new grants.
  • A company that is not granting options or other stock rights does not need a current 409A valuation.

How long does a 409A valuation stay valid?

A 409A valuation stays valid for up to 12 months from the valuation date, as long as nothing has happened since that date that may materially affect the value of the company. Both conditions must be met on the date an option is granted.

A 409A valuation is an independent appraisal of the fair market value of a private company’s common stock, used to set the exercise price of stock options. The validity rule comes from Treasury Regulation 1.409A-1(b)(5)(iv)(B). The regulation says a previously calculated value is not reasonable to use if it was calculated as of a date more than 12 months before the date it is used. The value is also not reasonable if it fails to reflect information that became available after the valuation date and may materially affect the value of the company.

An independent appraisal dated no more than 12 months before the grant gives the company a presumption that the value is reasonable. The IRS can overturn that presumption only by showing the valuation was grossly unreasonable. This protection is known as the 409A safe harbor, and the 12-month limit is one of its conditions.

When does the 12-month period start and end?

The 12-month period starts on the valuation date stated in the 409A report and is tested on each option grant date. The valuation date is the “as of” date the valuer used, which is often a month end. The date the report was delivered and the date the board approved the report do not restart the period.

The grant date is generally the date the board completes the corporate action needed to grant the option. It is not the date of the offer letter. An option promised in an offer letter in January and approved by the board in May is tested against the 409A valuation in May.

A 409A report is usually delivered some weeks after its valuation date, so the usable period is shorter than 12 months. The example below shows how the dates work for one report.

EventDateWhat it means
Valuation date stated in the 409A reportMarch 31, 2026The 12-month period starts
Report delivered to the companyApril 24, 2026The company can start granting at the new price
Board approves the valuation and the first grantsMay 5, 2026Inside the period
Last grant date the valuation can supportMarch 31, 2027Assumes no material event before this date
Board grants optionsApril 15, 2027Outside the period, although the report was delivered less than a year earlier

In this example the company gets about 11 months of use from the report, not 12. A company that counts from the delivery date would wrongly treat the April 15, 2027 grant as covered.

What makes a 409A valuation outdated before 12 months?

A 409A valuation becomes outdated before 12 months when new information may materially affect the value of the company. Valuers call this a material event. The regulation gives two examples: the resolution of material litigation and the issuance of a patent.

The regulation does not give a full list. In practice, valuers and auditors usually treat the following as material events:

  • A priced equity round, or a signed term sheet for one
  • An acquisition offer or a signed letter of intent
  • A secondary sale of shares at a price well above the 409A value
  • Winning or losing a major customer or contract
  • Results far ahead of, or far behind, the forecast used in the valuation

Whether an event is material is a judgment based on the facts. A priced round is the clearest case because it sets a new market price for the company’s shares, which is why companies get a new 409A valuation after a funding round before the next grant.

What happens if you grant options on an expired 409A valuation?

Options granted on an expired 409A valuation lose the presumption that the exercise price was set at fair market value. The grant is not automatically a violation. The company would have to prove, without the safe harbor, that the exercise price was at or above fair market value on the grant date.

If the exercise price turns out to be below fair market value on the grant date, the option is treated as deferred compensation under Section 409A. The option holder carries the tax cost. The deferred amount is included in the holder’s income, generally as the option vests, with an additional 20 percent federal tax and interest at the IRS underpayment rate plus 1 percentage point. The page on 409A penalties covers how the tax is worked out.

The problem often comes to light later, in a financial statement audit or in investor or buyer due diligence, when someone compares each grant date with the 409A valuation date behind it.

Do options you already granted need a new valuation when the 409A expires?

No. Fair market value is tested once, on the grant date. An option granted while the 409A valuation was valid stays properly priced after the valuation expires, even if the option is exercised years later.

The exception is a later change to the option. If the company reduces the exercise price or makes certain other changes, the change can be treated as a new grant, and the exercise price is tested against fair market value on the date of the change. That needs a valuation that is valid on that date.

When should you start the next 409A valuation?

Start the next 409A valuation early enough that the new report is approved before the first option grant that falls after the 12-month date. Work back from the board calendar, not from the old report.

  1. Take the valuation date from the report, not the delivery date, and mark the date 12 months later.
  2. List the board meetings or written consents planned for option grants over the next two quarters.
  3. Begin the new valuation about 30 to 45 days before the first grant date that falls after the 12-month date. This allows time to gather data, for the valuer to do the work and for the board to approve the report.
  4. If a priced round is expected to close soon, hold new grants and run the valuation after the closing, so the new report reflects the round.
  5. Before every grant, have the board confirm that the valuation date is within 12 months and that no material event has happened since. Record this in the minutes or the written consent.

For budgeting the renewal, see how much a 409A valuation costs.

What we see in practice

The most common mistake we see is counting the 12 months from the day the report arrived. The grant schedule assumes a full year from delivery, and the last one or two board grants fall after the true 12-month date. We also see options promised in offer letters and approved by the board months later, by which time the valuation has lapsed or a term sheet has been signed. The fix is the same in both cases. We tie the renewal date to the valuation date and to the board calendar, and the board checks both before it approves any grant.

When to get professional help

You need a new independent 409A valuation before the next option grant if any of these apply:

  • The grant date will fall more than 12 months after the valuation date.
  • The company has closed a priced round or signed a term sheet since the valuation date.
  • The company has received an acquisition offer, or shares have changed hands in a secondary sale.
  • Results are well ahead of, or well behind, the forecast used in the last valuation.

You do not need a new valuation yet if the company is not granting options or other stock rights in the coming months. An expired 409A valuation on its own does not trigger a filing or a penalty. If you are not sure the rule applies to your company at all, start with when a 409A valuation is required.

If you are unsure whether an event is material, ask a valuer before the grant, not after. CountSure prepares independent 409A valuations for private companies and can review whether your current report still supports a planned grant.

Frequently asked questions

Does a 409A valuation need to be renewed every year?

A 409A valuation needs to be renewed every year only if the company keeps granting options or other stock rights. Each grant must be backed by a valuation dated within the previous 12 months. A company that makes no grants for a period can let the valuation lapse and get a new one before the next grant.

Does signing a term sheet make a 409A valuation invalid?

A signed term sheet for a priced round is usually treated as a material event, because it is new information about what investors will pay for the company’s shares. Most companies stop granting options at the old price once a term sheet is signed and get a new 409A valuation after the round closes.

Who decides whether an event is material?

The board decides, because the board sets the exercise price at each grant. In practice the board relies on the valuer who prepared the report and on company counsel. The decision and the reasons should be recorded in the board minutes or written consent for the grant.

Can a new 409A valuation be lower than the previous one?

Yes. A 409A valuation reflects fair market value on its valuation date, and that value can fall if the company misses its forecast, loses a major customer or raises money at a lower price. Options granted after the new valuation can use the lower exercise price. Earlier grants keep their original price.

Is your 409A valuation close to its 12-month date?

Send us the valuation date from your current report and the date of your next board grant. We will tell you whether the report still supports the grant and what a new valuation involves.

This page gives general information and is not advice for a specific situation.

Go To Top Schedule Icon Schedule a Free Consultation